« Section 32: Problem 7 Solution

Section 32: Problem 9 Solution »

Section 32: Problem 8 Solution

Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
(a) is non-empty and closed, is a component of . If then is empty otherwise it is not. So, suppose it is not. Theorem 24.1 tells us that and all rays and intervals in are connected. Then and are in the same component of iff does not intersect . If is bounded below by a point not in , then let be the greatest lower bound of . Since is closed, (otherwise, let , , i.e. is not the largest element of , and every basis neighborhood of has a from where , but then there is an element , i.e. cannot be an interior point of ). Hence, if there is a component containing a lower bound of then it is of the form . Similarly, if there is a component containing an upper bound of then it is of the form . Now, suppose that is bounded below and above by points in . Let be its greatest lower bound and be its least upper bound. Neither nor belongs to (essentially, for the same reason). But for every there are points such that , therefore, . Hence, .(b) Suppose is a limit point of . If is in a component then, using (a), the component is a neighborhood of that contains only one point in , therefore, since the space is Hausdorff, must be equal to that point. Suppose now, . Then and each neighborhood of must contain infinite number of points in . Suppose are such points. lies within an interval with endpoints in and that contains neither nor . Therefore, is a limit point of , but is closed, so . This contradicts the assumption that they are disjoint. Similarly, cannot lie within . To sum up, only points in can be limit points of , i.e. is closed.(c) Using (a) and (b) we conclude that the components of are open intervals or rays. Then is an interval that does not contain points in . Suppose , and . Let be the greatest lower bound of points in . Then, as before, and contains no points in . Let be the lowest upper bound of points in . Then , and has no points in . Therefore, it is a component of with the endpoints in both and , and must have a point in . Contradiction.Conclusion. For choose those components of that contains points in (they do not contain points in ), and for choose all other components. Since intersects neither nor , we have open disjoint sets separating and .