Section 20: Problem 3 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
Let
be a metric space with metric
.
(a) Show that
is continuous.
(b) Let
denote a space having the same underlying set as
. Show that if
is continuous, then the topology of
is finer than the topology of
.
One can summarize the result of this exercise as follows: If
has a metric
, then the topology induced by
is the coarsest topology relative to which the function
is continuous.
(a) Let
be an open subset of
, and
. Then,
, and there is an open interval
. Take any point
. Then,
,
, and
is contained in
. Therefore, the set
open in
is such that
, and
is open.
(b) If
is continuous, then for every fixed
,
,
, is continuous (Exercise 11 of §18). Therefore, every
-ball
must be open in
.
We could have solved both (a) and (b) at once. Let
be the family of all topologies on
such that
is continuous. Then,
is nonempty, as, for example, the discrete topology on
is in
. Further, for every subfamily of topologies
,
is a topology on
(Exercise 4(a) of §13) such that
is continuous (the preimage of every open set is open relative to every topology in
, and, hence, relative to their intersection). Therefore,
is the coarsest topology relative to which
is continuous. It remains to note, that
is continuous relative to
iff
contains every ball
. Indeed, if
is continuous, then it must be continuous in each variable, and, in particular,
must be open for every
. And if every ball
is open, then
implies
where
, hence,
is open, and
is continuous. Therefore,
is the coarsest topology containing all balls
, which is the one generated by the balls as its basis (Exercise 5 of §13).