Section 30: Problem 1 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
(a) Let
be a countable basis at
. Then for each
there is a neighborhood
of
such that
does not contain
. Therefore, there is
that does not contain
. Thus,
.(b) Given any
and
there must be a neighborhood of
that does not contain
, therefore, the space is a
-space and every one-point set is closed. We can start with some first-countable
-space. By (a), every one-point set in such a space will be a
set. Then, if we take a finer topology, it will still have the property, however, we may loose the first-countability if the space is large enough. For example, if we take
then it is a metric space in the product topology. Therefore, every one-point set is the intersection of the countable collection of balls of radius
centered at the point. Now, if we switch to the box topology, then it seems not to satisfy the first-countability axiom (take a countable collection
of neighborhoods of a point and construct a neighborhood by taking the product of open proper subsets of
).Also, another example would be any countable
-space which is not first-countable. Such a space will also be separable and Lindelöf but not second-countable. One example of such a space I found by solving Exercise 17.