Section 22*: Problem 6 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
Recall that
denotes the real line in the
-topology. (See §13.) Let
be the quotient space obtained from
by collapsing the set
to a point; let
be the quotient map.
(a) Show that
satisfies the
axiom, but is not Hausdorff.
(b) Show that
is not a quotient map. [Hint: The diagonal is not closed in
, but its inverse image is closed in
.]
(a) Recall that the set
is closed in
(but not in
). Therefore, every one-point set
and
,
, in
is closed, and it is a
-topological space. At the same time, there is no neighborhood of
in
that does not contain points in
. Further, every neighborhood of
in
is of the form
or
where
is open in
, and, hence, contains a point
. Then,
intersects every neighborhood
of
in
. Overall, every neighborhood of
in
that does not contain
is of the form
, and every neighborhood of
is the union of some neighborhoods of all points of
in
, and the two must intersect as we said.
(b)
is not Hausdorff, therefore, the diagonal
of
is not closed (by (a), every neighborhood of
contains some
: see §17, Hausdorff Spaces). At the same time,
is closed as
is Hausdorff (the diagonal
is closed) and
is closed in
.
Note that
is not an open quotient map, in particular,
is not open as
has no neighborhood contained in
.