Section 19: Problem 10 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
Let
be a set; let
be an indexed family of spaces; and let
be an indexed family of functions
.
(a) Show there is a unique coarsest topology
on
relative to which each of the functions
is continuous.
(b) Let
and let
. Show that
is a subbasis for
.
(c) Show that a map
is continuous relative to
if and only if each map
is continuous.
(d) Let
be defined by the equation
let
denote the subspace
of the product space
. Show that the image under
of each element of
is an open set of
.
(a) Let
be the collection of topologies on
such that relative to each one each
is continuous.
is nonempty, as there exists at least one topology on
such that every function having
as its domain is continuous, namely, the discrete topology. The intersection of an arbitrary subcollection of
is a topology (Exercise 4(a) of §13) contained in
(for every open set
,
is open in every topology in the subcollection, hence, it is open in their intersection). Therefore,
is the coarsest topology such that relative to it each of the functions
is continuous. The uniqueness follows immediately, as the constructed topology must be a subset of any other topology in
.
(b) For every topology
, every set in
must be open in
, as every
is continuous relative to
. So, every topology in
contains
. On the other hand, if a topology on
contains
, then each
is continuous relative to this topology. So,
is exactly the collection of all topologies on
containing
. The coarsest such topology
is generated by
as a subbasis (Exercise 5 of §13).
Note, that (b) provides another way to construct
. A topology on
is in
iff it contains
. Hence, according to my solution of Exercise 4(b) of §13, there are two ways to construct the coarsest topology containing each
, namely, we can either consider the intersection of all topologies containing each
as in (a), or generate the topology from
as its subbasis. See also the discussion of the difference between the two methods from the point of view of their theoretical and practical values.
(c) Let
. Then if
is continuous, every
is continuous. If each
is continuous, then for every
open in
,
is the union of finite intersections of some subbasis elements
, where each
is open in
. Therefore,
is the union of finite intersections of
, and, hence, open in
.
(d) Let
and
. Take
such that
. Since
is open there is a basis element
in
such that
and
where
is open in
(without loss of generality all
’s are assumed to be distinct). For all other
’s assume
. Then,
and
. This set is open in the subspace topology (as only finitely many of
’s are distinct from their spaces) and
. Therefore,
is open in the subspace topology.