Section 35*: Problem 8 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
One direction: 6(a). The other direction: if a normal space is an absolute retract then it has the universal extension property. The idea, as I understand, is as follows: we consider a continuous function
from a closed subspace
of
to
; we know that whenever
is homeomorphic to a closed subspace of a normal space, the subspace is a retract, i.e. there exists a continuous map from the space onto the subspace that preserves all points of the subspace; but we need a continuous function from
to
that extends
; we consider the space which is the union of the spaces
and
and group some points into equivalence classes such that every point in
belongs to a separate class that also contains the preimage of the point; the union of all classes for all points in
is a closed subspace of the quotient space being homeomorphic to
; we show the quotient space is normal and consider a retraction from
onto the set of classes of points in
; now we can construct a continuous extension of
, as we shall see.Construct the adjunction space
as hinted: the quotient space obtained from
by identifying each point
with points in
(for this we, first, need to specify the topology on
: a set
is open in
iff
is open in
and
is open in
). Let
be the quotient map. Let
and denote elements of
as follows:
where
and
where
(if
then
contains only one element).First, we show that
is normal. Let
and
be closed in
. Let
and
.
are closed in
(
itself is closed as it contains all elements from
and
, both closed in
), therefore,
are closed in
and we can separate them by a continuous function
(Urysohn lemma). Now,
is continuous on
and
. We can extend it onto
:
. It is still continuous: it is continuous on
and
(the pasting lemma?). Now we can extend it onto
(Tietze theorem). Note that the extended
is constant on
for all
. Therefore, it induces a continuous function
on
(Section 22) such that it separates
and
. Hence,
is normal.Now, we show that
is homeomorphic to a closed subset of
, namely, to the set
. Indeed,
is continuous and bijective. It maps closed
to
which is the image of a closed saturated subset of
under the quotient map (
is closed in
which is closed in
).Finally, since
is a closed subset of the normal space
homeomorphic to
, and
is an absolute retract, there is a retraction
such that for every
:
. Let
.
is continuous, and maps
to
. For every
:
. Therefore,
extends
.