Section 67: Problem 3 Solution
Working problems is a crucial part of learning mathematics. No one can learn topology merely by poring over the definitions, theorems, and examples that are worked out in the text. One must work part of it out for oneself. To provide that opportunity is the purpose of the exercises.
James R. Munkres
If
is free abelian with basis
, show that
is also a basis for
.
Let
, and
. Then, if
, then
, hence,
and
, which has no more than 1 solution, hence,
forms a basis for the free subgroup generated by them.
However, I am not sure the subgroup is actually the whole group
. For example, even if we want to express
as a linear combination of
and
, we end up with the system of equations
and
, which implies
, but both
and
have to be integers.
For example, consider the set of all integer points of the
-plane with usual addition. It is a free abelian group having a basis
and
. Then, the points
and
generate all points of the form
, in particular, the sum of the coordinates of these points is always divisible by
. So, not every point can be express as a sum of elements of the groups generated by
and
.
I believe, this is a typo, and either the second one should be
, or the first one should be
. So, if we have
, then
implies
and
, or
, and
. Since
and
are determined uniquely by
, we conclude that so do
and
. Moreover,
implies
, and similarly for
. Hence,
is a free group having a basis
. Similarly, for
.